Sunday May 25, 2008
TO BE OR NOT TO BE A DON QUIJOTE
In 1605, Don Miguel de Cervantes Saavedra (1547-1616) has
published the first part of "El ingenioso hidalgo don Quijote de la
Mancha" (The ingenious knight don Quijote de la Mancha). After
publishing the second part, Cervantes has shorten the name of his work to "Don
Quijote de la Mancha". Fairly late, in 1885, Mr. John Ormsby (1829-1895) has
translated the book in English, though he made a horrible mistake: he has
renamed the book as "Don Quixote"!

Grammatical rules in English are very clear:
1. proper names, foreign or English, are written EXACTLY AS THEY ARE
ORIGINALLY; further, if the original phonetic pronunciation is difficult,
then it should be explained;
2. artistic or literary creations MUST KEEP THEIR ORIGINAL NAMES; any
translations of the original names come only as additional explanations.
Note that "Don Quijote de la Mancha" is not an ordinary novel--far form
that. In 2002, 100 "major writers"[SIC] from 54 countries have voted that "Don
Quijote de la Mancha" is the best work of fiction ever written. Of
course, we do not need any "major writers" to tell us that "Don Quijote
de la Mancha" is a good book; the book is very nice indeed. However, it
is interesting to note the chain of perpetual mistakes related to this
wonderful
literary creation.
First of all, it is impossible to explain why the entire English
world--better said, the English literary critics--persists in using the
pompous name "Don Quixote" for over 100 years! WHAT IS THAT?
It is obvious the English "major writers" adore their absurd, irrational
mistakes way more than the simple, plain truth--way to go sweet Ladies and
kind Gentleman "major writers"!
Secondly, there is the social-psychology aspect generated by the great
work of Don Cervantes. Any good book must have a message. In this particular
case, "Don Quijote de la Mancha", the message is, which is more
true/real: "normal people" or the "dreamers".
There are two types of people in our society: ordinary/normal people, the
vast majority, and the "dreamers". Ordinary people (the average, or "the
people" for short) live reality just as it is, with their feet firmly
planted on the ground. Particular to normal people is, for millennia, they
laughed at the "dreamers"--those who read too many books. In our particular
case, the "dreamer" Don Quijote is a very nice, innocent character who
loves life and he adores the people. Unfortunately for him, Don Quijote has
read the wrong books: the fantasy ones.
In the History of our Civilization have lived, possibly, few hundred
billions people. However, excepting few thousand remarkable "dreamers" as
was Aristotle, Archimedes, da Vinci, Newton, Laplace, Mendeleyev, etc. the
"normal people" have no names, no faces, no thoughts, nothing. All those
hundreds of billions of "real people", the normal ones, have vanished into
the indefinite concept of "the people"--they will always do. Of course, "the
people" have lived their lives in the present time, sharp and real, and they
enjoyed to the fullest the fruits of our
Civilization--in their real,
ordinary way. Overall, however, "normal people" are only the "background", the
social-environment in which the "dreamers" have to struggle to become NAMES.

The Global Picture is, despite the overwhelming reality, all those countless
masses of "normal people" mean absolutely nothing once they are gone;
they
will vanish for eternity into nothingness as if they never existed. In the
same time, those few
socially-ostracized "dreamers" today are the only TRUE
PEOPLE tomorrow: the only ones important, and the only "known people" who
ever lived on Earth.
For centuries people have laughed at Don Quijote--just an old, romantic
fool. Even more, to "show" they are so "smart" today, "some people" have
re-named our innocent, human, Don Quijote character--which defines the best
of us all--as "Don Quixote"! Such mockery! Anyway, those few,
good, nice,
intelligent, Don Quijote-like
people will continue living for as long our Civilization would continue to
exist.
*
THE MYSTERY OF THE GREAT ANIMAL MIGRATIONS
Although the topic is presented only summarily, it is worth reading it; just
follow this BBC link.
It is possible we will develop this topic in one of our future
Amazing Articles, because animal migrations are
still a great, unexplained mystery on our planet.
***
|